Drawing of a small fish and a shrimp sharing a planted aquarium

Which Fish Can Live with Shrimp? Safe, Risky and Never

Our verdict: the safest tank for shrimp has no fish at all, especially if you want them to breed. If you want some movement, choose tiny, peaceful fish (such as chilli rasboras) or algae-eating catfish (such as otocinclus), and expect to lose a few baby shrimp.

Practical Fishkeeping’s Nathan Hill puts it simply: many fish will eat anything that fits in their mouth, but not all do. Some fish are able to eat shrimp and still ignore them, and others eat only the young. That is why advice on forums varies so much. Here is how the sources sort the options.

Safe for shrimp of all sizes

  • Algae eaters. Practical Fishkeeping says that if a fish is an algae grazer it is not interested in, or often even capable of, eating shrimp. It names Otocinclus and their cousins Parotocinclus and Hypoptopoma as the main candidates, plus slender suckermouths such as Farlowella for larger tanks. It calls them drab and shy.
  • Dwarf rasboras of the genus Boraras, such as the chilli rasbora. They are small, colourful and have tiny mouths, so, according to the same article, any losses will be the youngest baby shrimp.

Maybe: they will probably eat the young

Practical Fishkeeping lists guppies, rasboras, small danios, kuhli loaches, pencilfish, clown killifish, corydoras, White Cloud Mountain minnows and small rainbowfish of the Pseudomugilidae family here. These will almost certainly eat shrimp babies, so it only suits you if you do not care about breeding. Let the shrimp colony build up before adding fish, and offer plenty of plants and hiding places. Shrimp Science makes the same point and adds that neon tetras may work if the shrimp have lots of cover, but the risk to baby shrimp is much higher, so do not put fish in a breeding tank.

Two fish are a gamble. Practical Fishkeeping says a betta may ignore shrimp completely or clear out a colony in days, and that dwarf puffers are likewise a gamble that may not pay off. It describes success as down to an individual fish’s “personality” and chance.

Not with shrimp

  • Large fish in general, and members of the cichlid family. Practical Fishkeeping includes angelfish and discus, and says even dwarf cichlids are “hunting machines”.
  • Goldfish, large rainbowfish, large gouramis, spiny eels, larger livebearers and most loaches: the author says it is a matter of when, not if.
  • Larger tetras and barbs, in the author’s own opinion, though some hobbyists report success.
  • For bamboo shrimp, Fishkeeper also says to avoid pufferfish, large barbs, large aggressive botiid loaches and most cichlids.

Amano shrimp are bigger and may survive with some fish, but Practical Fishkeeping says they will certainly hide.

Other costs of mixing fish and shrimp

  • Hiding and fewer babies. With predators around, shrimp hide more and breed less. If you see berried females but no young, check what else is in the tank.
  • Competition at feeding time. Fish usually reach food first.
  • Water changes. Fish keepers tend to do large, frequent water changes, which shrimp dislike. They can trigger premature moults.
  • Different water. A recent trend of keeping hillstream loaches with shrimp is an example: the loaches want torrential flow that shrimp cannot handle.
  • Medication. Many fish medications are not safe for invertebrates (see copper and other things that kill shrimp).
  • Deaths. A hidden dead fish or large snail can cause an ammonia spike that kills the colony.

Before you decide, see what a shrimp-only tank involves in our beginner guide, and check hardness needs in shrimp water parameters. Our stocking checker was built for fish, so do not rely on it to tell you whether a fish will eat shrimp.

Sources

Most of this guide rests on one magazine article, which itself says that experiences vary and that some hobbyists have kept “unsafe” fish with shrimp successfully. Treat every fish other than the algae eaters as a risk. Our verdict is our own judgement. See how we use sources.

Get new guides by email

New fish profiles and guides, in one short email. No spam, unsubscribe any time. See our privacy policy.