Our verdict: start with Neocaridina (cherry shrimp and their colour forms). They accept a wide range of tap water. Bee shrimp (Caridina) are rewarding but need softer, more acidic water, usually reverse-osmosis (RO) water and a special substrate, so they suit a second shrimp tank better than a first.
Almost every colourful dwarf shrimp on sale belongs to one of two groups. Cherry shrimp (Neocaridina davidi) and their yellow, blue, black and green forms are one species. Crystal red, crystal black and Taiwan bee shrimp are selectively bred forms of Caridina cantonensis. They look alike at a glance, but they live in different water.
Side by side
| Neocaridina (cherry shrimp) | Caridina cantonensis (crystal, bee) | |
|---|---|---|
| Temperature | 15 to 30 °C tolerated (Shrimp Science); 18 to 26 °C (Practical Fishkeeping) | 20 to 25 °C (Shrimp Science); 18 to 25 °C (Fishkeeper); 18 to 23 °C (Practical Fishkeeping) |
| pH | 6.5 to 8 | about 5.5 to 7 |
| Hardness | medium to hard; GH 4 to 10 (Shrimp Science) or 8 to 18 °dH (Practical Fishkeeping) | soft; GH about 4 to 6, KH 0 to 2 |
| Substrate | sand works well | active shrimp soil helps hold the pH |
| Water source | dechlorinated tap water often works, sometimes mixed with RO | usually RO water plus a GH-only mineral supplement |
| Difficulty | easy | medium |
Where the sources disagree
- Cherry shrimp hardness: Shrimp Science gives GH 4 to 10 and KH 1 to 8. Practical Fishkeeping gives 8 to 18 °dH and KH 5 to 15. Only the 8 to 10 GH range overlaps, so treat the ranges as “tolerated”, not “ideal”. If your shrimp breed and moult cleanly, leave the water alone.
- Mixing the two groups: Shrimp Science says a crystal red can share a tank with cherries because it tolerates a pH around 7. Fishkeeper advises against it because the temperature needs differ. We would not mix them: the water that suits one is a compromise for the other.
- Bee shrimp species name: Shrimp Science and Fishkeeper place crystal shrimp under Caridina cantonensis. Practical Fishkeeping names the bee shrimp Caridina logemanni and the tiger shrimp Caridina mariae, along with their hybrids. Taxonomy of these cultivated forms is not settled.
- Bee shrimp KH: Shrimp Science and Practical Fishkeeping say 0 to 2. Fishkeeper says up to 8, but also notes hard, alkaline water is best avoided. We follow the lower figure.
Colour forms and crossbreeding
All cherry shrimp colour forms are one species and need the same water. They also interbreed. Practical Fishkeeping warns not to keep several forms together, because the young drift back towards the plain brownish wild type within a few generations. Shrimp Science describes the same effect: mixed colours usually give a lower-grade version of one parent.
Caridina behave differently. According to Practical Fishkeeping they do not revert to a wild form when crossed, which is why breeders can create new patterns. If you want uniform shrimp, keep one variety.
Water and substrate
- Cherry shrimp: check your tap water first with our hardness guide and the hardness converter. Practical Fishkeeping says low-nitrate, low-phosphate tap water can be used after dechlorinating, or mixed with RO water to soften it.
- Bee shrimp: Practical Fishkeeping says most keepers use pure RO water remineralised with a GH-boosting product, and sometimes baking soda to add a little carbonate hardness. Our RO water mixing calculator helps with the maths.
- Active substrates: these hold the pH down for a long time, but some release ammonia for a couple of weeks. Make sure the tank is fully cycled before the shrimp go in (see how to cycle a new aquarium).
- Heater: Practical Fishkeeping says neither group needs one at normal room temperature. Shrimp Science says a heater is optional for crystal shrimp if the room stays around 20 °C.
Which should you pick?
Our advice, not a source’s: choose cherry shrimp if this is your first shrimp tank or your tap water is medium to hard. Choose crystal or bee shrimp only once you have kept a stable tank for a while, and are happy to measure GH, KH and pH and prepare RO water for every water change. Both groups share the basics in our shrimp-only aquarium guide: a mature tank, gentle filtration and no copper.
Other shrimp worth knowing
- Amano shrimp are also Caridina but far less fussy. They are bigger, and their young need salty water, so they will not overrun a tank.
- Sulawesi shrimp, such as the cardinal shrimp, need warm, alkaline water and are not for beginners.
- Bamboo shrimp are filter feeders that need strong flow and fine food.
Sources
- Practical Fishkeeping: An introduction to Shrimp (Gabor Horvath, 2021, updated 2025)
- Shrimp Science: Red Cherry Shrimp care guide
- Shrimp Science: Crystal Red Shrimp care guide
- Fishkeeper (Maidenhead Aquatics): Crystal Red Shrimp
Figures are ranges across these sources; where they disagree we say so. The choice of which group to start with is our own judgement. Shrimp Science and Fishkeeper are hobby and retail sites. See how we use sources.

